Blog Posts - Safety Evolution

What Is the Hierarchy of Controls? OSHA Examples & How to Apply It

Written by Safety Evolution | Nov 20, 2025 7:42:59 PM

If you’re responsible for workers in construction, field services, or industrial operations, you’ve probably heard about the hierarchy of hazard controls, but maybe not in a way that feels practical on a busy jobsite.

The hierarchy of controls is OSHA and NIOSH’s preferred way to control hazards, ranking methods from most effective (elimination) to least effective (PPE).(CDC)

When you really understand it and build it into your safety program, training, and systems, you don’t just reduce risk. You lower costs, avoid rework, win better contracts, and turn safety into a profitable part of your business. That’s exactly what Safety Evolution helps companies do with safety software, training courses, and professional safety services.

 

What This Guide Covers

In this guide, you’ll learn:

  • What the hierarchy of controls is (OSHA & NIOSH view)

  • The five levels: elimination, substitution, engineering, administrative, PPE

  • Practical examples for construction, service companies, and manufacturing

  • How to actually apply the hierarchy during hazard assessments, JSAs, and SOP design

  • Common mistakes (like jumping straight to PPE)

  • Where training (OSHA 10/30 & task-specific courses) and software support real-world implementation

Why This Topic Matters for Safety Teams

For construction owners, service company owners, and HSE managers, the hierarchy of hazard controls is more than a textbook pyramid:

  • It’s how you decide which controls are worth investing in

  • It shapes your equipment choices, designs, and work methods

  • It directly impacts incident rates, insurance premiums, and project profitability

  • It’s embedded in OSHA and NIOSH guidance on controlling exposures(CDC)

Teams that truly use the hierarchy of controls:

  • Have fewer recordable incidents, less downtime, and fewer surprise costs

  • Spend less time chasing paperwork and more time doing productive work

  • Can prove due diligence when clients, auditors, or regulators ask questions

Safety Evolution’s role is to make this practical: using digital safety management, structured training, and consulting to help you implement higher-level controls. Consistently and profitably.

The Core Topic Explained: What Is the Hierarchy of Controls?

Definition

The hierarchy of controls is a ranked system for controlling workplace hazards, from most effective to least effective:(CDC)

  1. Elimination – Remove the hazard completely

  2. Substitution – Replace it with something safer

  3. Engineering Controls – Isolate people from the hazard

  4. Administrative Controls – Change how people work

  5. Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) – Protect the worker with gear

NIOSH and OSHA promote this approach because higher-level controls (elimination, substitution, engineering) do not rely heavily on human behavior, while administrative controls and PPE do.(CDC)

Why It Exists

  • Not all controls are equal: some remove the hazard, others just reduce exposure

  • It helps employers prioritize investments: spend first on controls that give the biggest reduction in risk

  • It drives safety professionals to fix the system, not just “blame the worker”

When business owners understand this hierarchy, safety conversations shift from “Did they wear PPE?” to “How can we design this job so the hazard is gone or contained?”

U.S. GEO-Relevant Insights (OSHA & NIOSH)

In the United States:

  • NIOSH describes the hierarchy of controls as the preferred order of actions to control workplace exposures, starting with elimination and substitution, followed by engineering, administrative controls, and PPE.(CDC)

  • OSHA references the hierarchy when discussing controlling exposures to hazards like chemicals and toxic substances.(OSHA)

  • The hierarchy aligns with OSHA expectations under the General Duty Clause—you must furnish a workplace free from recognized hazards where feasible.

For U.S. employers, using the hierarchy of hazard controls isn’t just “best practice,” it’s closely tied to how OSHA expects you to reason about hazards, corrective actions, and feasibility.

Step-by-Step Framework: Applying the Hierarchy of Controls

Here’s a simple, repeatable process your supervisors and HSE team can use.

Step 1 – Identify the Hazard Clearly

  • Use inspections, JSAs/JHAs, incident reports, worker input

  • Describe the hazard in plain language: “Unprotected edge at 14 feet,” not just “fall hazard”

Step 2 – Challenge Yourself at the Top of the Hierarchy

Ask, in order:

  1. Can we eliminate it?

    • Change the design or process so the hazard is gone

    • Example: Prefabricate components at ground level instead of working at height

  2. If not, can we substitute?

    • Swap tools, chemicals, or processes for safer ones

    • Example: Use a less-toxic solvent; use battery-powered tools instead of corded ones

  3. If not, what engineering controls are possible?

    • Guarding, barriers, ventilation, automation, interlocks

Only after exhausting these do you move to:

  1. Administrative controls – Procedures, training, rotation, permits, checklists

  2. PPE – Hard hats, gloves, respirators, fall protection, etc.

Step 3 – Document the Rationale

  • Record what options you considered and why

  • This is where safety software helps: link hazards, controls, tasks, and training records in one place

Step 4 – Train & Communicate

  • Integrate new controls into SOPs, toolbox talks, and formal courses like OSHA 10, OSHA 30, hazard communication, and task-specific training

  • Track completion using your LMS or safety platform

Step 5 – Verify & Improve

  • Inspect controls regularly

  • Ask workers if the control works in real-life conditions

  • Adjust as needed and update your hierarchy-based assessments

The Five Levels of the Hierarchy (With Examples)

1. Elimination (Most Effective)

Definition: Remove the hazard so exposure is impossible.(CDC)

Examples for your world:

  • Construction: Design rooftop equipment so it’s accessible from ground level; remove unnecessary roof work

  • Service companies: Use remote diagnostics instead of climbing into hazardous spaces

  • Manufacturing: Remove a manual cutting process by switching to a safer prefabricated component

2. Substitution

Definition: Replace the hazard with something less hazardous.(CDC)

Examples:

  • Swap a solvent with a lower VOC or lower toxicity

  • Use quieter equipment to reduce noise exposure

  • Replace a high-energy tool with a lower-risk alternative

3. Engineering Controls

Definition: Isolate people from the hazard through physical means.(CDC)

Examples:

  • Guardrails and leading-edge protection for work at heights

  • Machine guarding, interlocks, and light curtains

  • Local exhaust ventilation on welding stations

  • Enclosed chemical mixing stations

4. Administrative Controls

Definition: Change the way people work: policies, procedures, and scheduling.(CDC)

Examples:

  • Job rotation to limit noise or heat exposure

  • Permit-to-work systems for confined spaces or hot work

  • Standard operating procedures (SOPs) and checklists

  • Toolbox talks, task briefings, and documented JSAs

5. PPE (Least Effective Alone)

Definition: Equipment worn by workers to reduce exposure.

Examples:

  • Hard hats, safety glasses, gloves

  • Hearing protection, respirators

  • Fall arrest harnesses and lanyards

PPE is still essential, but it should be the last line of defense, not the first solution.

Real-World Scenarios (Construction, Service, Manufacturing)

Scenario 1 – Fall Risk on a Roof (Construction)

  • Hazard: Workers installing HVAC units on a high roof

  • Better Approach Using the Hierarchy:

    • Elimination: Design project so units are installed at ground level and craned fully assembled

    • Engineering: Install permanent guardrails or parapets

    • Administrative: Create a rooftop access permit and work procedures

    • PPE: Full fall protection system, harness, and training

Where Safety Evolution helps:

Scenario 2 – Chemical Use in a Service or Maintenance Shop

  • Hazard: Technicians using a harsh degreasing solvent

  • Hierarchy in Action:

    • Substitution: Switch to a less hazardous product

    • Engineering: Add local exhaust or enclosed cleaning systems

    • Administrative: Written procedure, storage rules, spill response

    • PPE: Chemical-resistant gloves, goggles, aprons

Support from Safety Evolution:

  • Build chemical-specific SOPs, attach SDS, and track training in the system

  • Deliver hazard communication, PPE, and chemical handling courses

Scenario 3 – Noise in Manufacturing

  • Hazard: Prolonged exposure to high noise levels

  • Hierarchy in Action:

    • Elimination/Substitution: Replace the loudest equipment with quieter models

    • Engineering: Enclose machines, add acoustic panels

    • Administrative: Rotate staff, enforce quiet zones, limit exposure time

    • PPE: Hearing protection and audiometric testing

How we fit:

Common Mistakes & How to Fix Them

Mistake 1: Jumping straight to PPE

  • Fix: During JSAs and incident reviews, force the team to walk the hierarchy from elimination downwards, not from PPE upwards.

Mistake 2: Treating the hierarchy as “one-and-done”

  • Fix: Revisit controls after changes in equipment, processes, or incidents. Make review part of your safety management cycle.

Mistake 3: No documentation of why certain controls were chosen

  • Fix: Use a digital system to record assessed options, feasibility, and final decisions. This protects you with OSHA and clients.

Mistake 4: Training not aligned to controls

  • Fix: If you add or change controls, update training immediately. Toolbox talks plus formal courses like OSHA 10, OSHA 30, fall protection, lockout/tagout, confined space, hazard communication, and equipment-specific courses through Safety Evolution’s training catalog.

Mistake 5: Not leveraging higher-level controls because of cost

  • Fix: Calculate long-term savings: fewer incidents, less downtime, better bid compliance. Higher-level controls often pay for themselves and your safety program becomes a profit lever, not just a cost center.

FAQs

Q1. What is the hierarchy of hazard controls in OSHA/NIOSH terms?
The hierarchy of hazard controls is a ranked approach to controlling workplace hazards: elimination, substitution, engineering controls, administrative controls, and personal protective equipment, from most effective to least effective.(CDC)

Q2. Why is elimination at the top of the hierarchy of controls?
Because eliminating the hazard removes the risk entirely. No exposure, no chance of harm, making it the most effective control.

Q3. What is an example of the hierarchy of controls in construction?
For work at heights, you might design out the elevation (elimination), use prefabrication at ground level (substitution), install guardrails (engineering), implement rooftop permits and work plans (administrative), and provide fall arrest PPE as a last resort.

Q4. How does the hierarchy of controls relate to OSHA compliance?
OSHA expects employers to use feasible engineering and administrative controls before relying solely on PPE when controlling exposures to hazards like chemicals, noise, and physical risks.(OSHA)

Q5. How can software support the hierarchy of controls?
Digital safety software lets you log hazards, link them to specific controls, track corrective actions, attach JSAs and SOPs, and connect all of it to training and inspections. Creating a closed-loop system.

Q6. Which training courses help workers apply the hierarchy of controls?
Courses like OSHA 10, OSHA 30, hazard communication, fall protection, lockout/tagout, confined space, and equipment-specific training all reinforce hazard recognition and the application of the hierarchy of controls. You can deliver and track these through Safety Evolution’s training programs.

Q7. Does the hierarchy of controls apply to service companies as well as plants and jobsites?
Yes. The hierarchy of controls is universal, it applies to field technicians, facility maintenance, shops, and offices just as much as large construction or manufacturing sites.(HSE Study Guide)

Summary & Key Takeaways

  • The hierarchy of hazard controls ranks control methods from most to least effective: elimination, substitution, engineering, administrative, PPE.(CDC)

  • OSHA and NIOSH expect employers to prioritize higher-level controls wherever feasible.

  • Applying the hierarchy systematically turns safety from a reactive obligation into a strategic, profitable part of your business.

  • Real value comes when the hierarchy is built into hazard assessments, JSAs, SOPs, training, and digital systems.

  • Training (OSHA 10/30 and task-specific courses), software, and consulting make it realistic to apply at scale.

If you want a safety program that’s compliant, defensible, and profitable, Safety Evolution can help you operationalize the hierarchy of controls across your organization.

 



Sign up below for our weekly newsletter with helpful safety content, including weekly toolbox talks!